Best Italian restaurant in Arlington — historical results
ClosedClosed 3/7/2025
Final results
3273 votes
The Italian Store1170 · 35.8%
Carbonara453 · 13.8%
Sfoglina306 · 9.3%
Osteria da Nino Italian Ristorante262 · 8.0%
Pupatella236 · 7.2%
A Modo Mio180 · 5.5%
pie-tanza150 · 4.6%
Pines of Florence147 · 4.5%
Other:133 · 4.1%
Mele Bistro60 · 1.8%
Federico Ristorante Italiano57 · 1.7%
Mazaro Italian Restaurant44 · 1.3%
La Bettola Italiano40 · 1.2%
Troy's Italian Restaurant35 · 1.1%