Best ice cream shop in Alexandria — historical results
ClosedClosed 6/26/2026
Final results
912 votes
The Dairy Godmother245 · 26.9%
Pop's Old Fashion Ice Cream Co181 · 19.9%
Casa Rosada Artisan Gelato135 · 14.8%
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams88 · 9.7%
Goodies Frozen Custard & Treats67 · 7.3%
Dolci Gelati47 · 5.2%
The Creamery38 · 4.2%
Pitango Gelato & Coffee31 · 3.4%
Kilwins28 · 3.1%
Other:19 · 2.1%
Ben & Jerry’s15 · 1.6%
The Sweetside Cafe & Creamery12 · 1.3%
Lil’ Cakes & Creamery6 · 0.7%