Best ice cream shop in Arlington — historical results
ClosedClosed 5/23/2025
Final results
1871 votes
Toby's Homemade Ice Cream866 · 46.3%
Nicecream214 · 11.4%
Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams203 · 10.8%
Ice Cream Jubilee153 · 8.2%
Mimi's Handmade Ice Cream126 · 6.7%
Carvel101 · 5.4%
Cold Stone Creamery90 · 4.8%
Van Leeuwen51 · 2.7%
Other:35 · 1.9%
La Moo Creamery25 · 1.3%
MidnighTreats7 · 0.4%